Just Put Away The Saltshakers
It isn’t like that, at all. There are quite a few things I really liked about June Hur’s debut Silence of Bones. I’m not about to go salty on this book at all. Having said that, while there are elements about it that I really enjoyed? There were other arts that left me either completely confused or were utterly predictable. I would almost rather outright hate it because I feel like a really fantastic half of book was wasted. But such is life and as I stated recently, all things considered? Overall, backlists and ARCs included? I’ve been one lucky son of a bitch. I’ve had mostly, some fantastic reads.
Upfront disclaimer, I have always been a fan of fictional “time-period,” cultural books, as well as alternative history. Part of why I wanted to read Silence of Bones is because I hadn’t read one set in 1800’s (Joseon) Korea. While I absolutely do not claim any expertise on the time period or culture, from all indications I’ve seen (and yes, in this instance I did look around at reviews because I know that this is not my lane or expertise), Hur did an incredible job building the world.
It truly came alive whether they were around the capital, in dense forests or rushing rivers. Hur utilized every aspect of the culture at that time to bring the world’s identity to life, as well. She did not shy away from how horrifically servants were treated, punished, and manipulated. Physical violence and torture were described in devastating detail. This was never done in a way to just bring shock value to the story, but to engross the reader into what that time and place was like for both the high-borne and those they stepped on without mercy, every day.
Internal and external strife also brought deep rooted mistrust of … well just about everyone. It was so entranced in society that it was rotted just about everything and everyone. To leave out either the internal enemies and only focus on those coming from the west, or only focus on the internal enemies and not those of the west, would have left a gaping hole in not just the story, but the characters motives and emotions.
Hur masterfully takes each piece of the above and blends them together to provide a complete, complex, and dynamic picture of this period of Korean history.
Along with classism, Hur wasn’t afraid to stick a kick-ass female hero into this time period. Is it realistic for the time period? You could argue the point except this is fiction and that kind of is the point, in my opinion. I’d rather say Hur wrote a dynamic, realistic female character that was far from perfect, but strong enough to keep going throughout her imperfections.
Thank you to Feiwel & Friends for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
They got her into some real shit-shows at time, but she didn’t let it stop her. Her self-dialogue was pretty spectacular at times. Whether talking herself out of fear, through the idea of keep on, keeping on or how to get herself out of hopeless situation? Hur gave us a female heroine who earned the respect of many that would normally not give a branded girl the time of day. One that in her imperfections, was easy to root for, in a time period when there shouldn’t have been any, at all.
See. Here in lies the problem. Or part of it, at least. The mystery is well a mystery. And then it isn’t. On one hand it is a convoluted, complicated, confusing, what the mess…. mess. Then on the other hand? What I could understand? Was completely predictable. I know. That doesn’t really make much sense. How can something that is completely confusing also be completely predictable? Let me try to explain.
There were parts of the plot that I could easily see coming (of course this will stay general for the sake of spoilers).
- The arcs of certain characters.
- The relationships (not romantic relationships because COMPLETE BONUS POINTS TO SILENCE OF BONES BECAUSE- NO ROMANCE) that formed between characters.
- Character roles such as: actual wrong doers, being framed, red herrings, liars etc…
- The twists and turns weren’t twisty or turny– well not in a good way.
Then there was the confusion.
Hey, you know that comparison I sometimes like to give about Marvel’s Infinity War? How there is SO MUCH BOOK IN A BOOK. Like Honest Trailer says about Avengers: Infinity War? There is SO MUCH MOVIE IN THAT MOVIE. Usually, like Honest Trailers says, it is a compliment. This time? Not so much.
Oh for those that haven’t seen it (even if you have, you can’t watch it enough)…
Every time I thought I had a grasp on what was happening beyond the utter predictability of the above. Hur dropped new characters and plot angles into the story. OR even better, both, AT ONCE. And then the other part that I was just reading about was, poof, snapped like at the end of Infinity War. The attempts to tie it together at the end didn’t seem at all worth it. The pay-off wasn’t nearly enough. I either knew what it was coming or was just like… meh… OR had to go back and reread to figure out what that specific reveal even meant to the story.
The Conflict Is High With This One
There are some real high points with the world-building, themes and the lead character. It is with the mystery side of the story that Silence of Bones falls apart. It is a shame because this book had such huge potential for me. I was really looking forward to it. And while I didn’t hate it? I almost feel more empty being in this in-between grey world where I can’t make heads or tails of how I feel. YMMV…
7 thoughts on “Silence of Bones by June Hur Releases Today With Real Strengths And Then Not So Much… YMMV”
Sorry this didn’t quite work for you. I’ve definitely read books like that, which end up in some confused middle ground because you love half and hate half. Sounds like an author to watch for more books from, though, since this is a debut. I’m definitely interested in the setting, though, and I might have to check out the book just for the historical fiction aspect of it. :3
I agree. It is their debut novel and definitely one to keep an eye out for. Some will definitely love it. I wouldn’t hesitate to tell you to check it out!
Wow, amazing review! I knew that this wasn’t the book for me from the description–I don’t gravitate toward historical fiction–but mixed with a thriller/mystery it did have me a little curious. I maybe could have been persuaded to try it if the reviews were really great but I will take your word for it.
Thank you! Yeah the mystery got bogged down for me with everything that kept getting thrown on top of it. It just murkied everything up.
Oh man, I’ve read some books like this before. It’s either mediocre (with the starting potential to be brilliant) or leaves me with a headache or sometimes both. Most times it seems to be a bit of both. Great review Susan, you really explained the confusing aspects of this book well. Jen
Thank you! Its hard when you are middle of the road on a book. You keep going but don’t know whether itll pan out. Some parts you love and then some parts make you want to cringe. Like Sam said this is the first book by the author though so I wouldnt hesitate to see what she does next. This one was just too head splitting like you said.